The Art of Thinking and Reasoning vs Judgmental Thinking

An Analysis of Induction, Deduction, Assumptions and Hypotheses


In a society characterized by diverse perspectives, how individuals engage in cognitive processes plays an influential role in shaping their comprehension of the world. This article delves into the intriguing realm of human cognition, exploring distinctions between scientific thinking and other forms of judgmental approaches. It will delve into how scientific thinking not only differentiates itself but also provides a potent instrument for recognizing and rectifying errors while safeguarding against pitfalls associated with judgmental thinking and hypocrisy.

1. Understanding Modes of Thinking: Induction, Deduction, Assumptions, and Hypotheses:

In the realm of thinking and reasoning, individuals possess a range of cognitive techniques to draw upon. These include inductive and deductive reasoning, as well as the utilization of assumptions and hypotheses.

Inductive reasoning involves reaching general conclusions based on specific observations. For instance, if every cat you’ve encountered is furry, you might deduce that all cats are also furry. Inductive thinking allows us to use specific data and observations to draw credible and valid conclusions, even without prior knowledge of the subject matter.

Deduction, on the other hand, starts with a general premise and moves to a specific conclusion. It’s the classic “if-then” logic, where if the premise is true, the conclusion must also be true. For example, if all dogs have four legs, and Spot is a dog, then it can be deduced that Spot has four legs. Deductive reasoning requires one to have prior knowledge about certain theories of concepts that are already acceptable and considered factual to conclude from. From the premise of a general rule, deductive reasoning ensures the derivation of logically secure conclusions or a series of conclusions(Wang et al., 2020).

Assumptions are the often-unconscious beliefs and ideas we hold about the world. These assumptions shape our perceptions and influence our thinking. They can guide our reasoning and help us make sense of new information, but they can also limit our understanding if they are based on incorrect or biased beliefs. The assumption is scientific because it involves making initial suppositions or beliefs that guide the process of reasoning and exploration. It is important to recognize and critically examine our assumptions to ensure they are grounded in evidence and logic. You assume by basing your supposition or belief on a piece of existing and factual evidence. An assumption guides our reasoning from which another scientific thinking can branch out – like making a hypothesis.

Hypotheses are educated guesses or predictions that serve as a starting point for scientific investigation. A hypothesis like an assumption is an initial supposition but differs in that it is testable and can be proven or disproven through experimentation or observation. Testing hypotheses require extensive research and data collection to gather evidence that either supports or refutes the hypothesis.

2. The Lure of Judgmental Thinking: Jumping to Conclusions and Hypocrisy:

Humans often succumb to the temptation of making rapid judgments, a natural cognitive inclination that has evolved over millennia as an adaptive strategy. Nevertheless, this predisposition can give rise to erroneous assessments and even instances of hypocrisy. For example, when people engage in judgmental thinking, they may jump to conclusions without gathering all the available information or considering alternative perspectives.

This can lead to biased and inaccurate judgments, which can have negative consequences for individuals and society as a whole.

Rushing to conclusions is a common error that happens when individuals make hasty judgments without substantial evidence. It can be likened to making assumptions about the content of a book solely based on its title. Jumping to conclusions overlooks the need for careful evaluation and critical thinking, potentially leading to incorrect judgments and misunderstandings. Moreover, jumping to conclusions can be exacerbated by cognitive distortions, which are faulty patterns of thinking that can cloud our judgment. This differs from a scientific assumption in the sense that jumping to conclusions is based on limited information and a lack of logical reasoning, whereas assumptions in scientific thinking are grounded in evidence and logical reasoning.

Hypocrisy becomes evident when individuals hold others to standards that they do not adhere to themselves. It is common for us to criticize someone for engaging in a behavior that we also partake in, whether knowingly or unknowingly.

This hypocritical tendency arises from a lack of self-awareness and an inability to recognize our faults or inconsistencies. Furthermore, hypocrisy often stems from a failure to apply the same standards or principles to ourselves as we do to others. This can result in a moral double standard, wherein we judge others more harshly for their actions while excusing or justifying our similar behavior.

3. The Scientific Way of Thinking:

Scientific thinking represents a distinctive approach to comprehending the world. It entails a dedication to objectivity, skepticism, and empirical observation.

Objectivity serves as a safeguard against personal biases and emotions that may hinder one’s judgment. The emphasis lies in scrutinizing the evidence, even if it contradicts preconceived notions.

Skepticism fosters an attitude of questioning everything. In the realm of science, nothing is accepted at face value; all claims must endure rigorous scrutiny.

Empirical observation mandates that conclusions rest upon observable and measurable evidence. If something cannot be seen, touched, or measured, it falls outside the purview of scientific methodology.

4. A Shield Against Errors: How Scientific Thinking Differs:

One of the fundamental distinctions between scientific thinking and judgmental thinking is the commitment to critical evaluation inherent in scientific practice. In the field of science, it is not only acceptable but also expected to thoroughly consider alternative explanations and remain open to revising one’s views when new evidence arises. This stands in contrast to judgemental thinking, which often exhibits rigidity and reluctance towards change. The adaptability associated with scientific thinking facilitates continuous growth and refinement of ideas throughout time. Scientific thinking also involves the use of induction and deduction to arrive at conclusions.

5. Justifying and Correcting Mistakes within Scientific Thinking:

What distinguishes scientific thinking is its recognition of mistakes as an inherent aspect of the process. Errors are deemed justifiable if they contribute to a deeper comprehension of the world.

Scientific methodology possesses an intrinsic self-correcting quality, incorporating mechanisms such as peer review and experiment replication to detect and rectify errors.

6. The Wider Implications: Why Scientific Thinking Matters:

The ability to think scientifically is not confined to scientists alone. It is a skill that can benefit individuals from all walks of life. By applying the principles and methods of scientific thinking, we can make more informed decisions in our daily lives.

In a society that values evidence-based reasoning, rational policy decisions are more likely to be made, thereby fostering progress and promoting innovation. Furthermore, scientific thinking encourages a healthy skepticism towards information and claims that are not supported by empirical evidence.


Scientific thinking isn’t reserved solely for the realm of scientists. It offers a potent antidote to the pitfalls of judgmental thinking, jumping to conclusions, and hypocrisy. By embracing the principles of scientific thinking—open-mindedness, empirical observation, and self-correction—we can cultivate a more rational and enlightened approach to understanding the world around us. So, let’s celebrate the power of scientific thinking and strive to apply it in our daily lives, thereby contributing to a more informed and harmonious society.





Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *